Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies 9RS0
Philosophy of ReligionPaper
Religion and EthicsPaper
New Testament StudiesPaper
BuddhismReligion
ChristianityReligion
HinduismReligion
IslamReligion
JudaismReligion
SikhismReligion
Christianity
God as Personal and as Creator
- 3 things to know
- Paper 4
Overview
Recall questions on God as personal, Buber's two kinds of relation and Augustine, omnipotence and immutability, creation from nothing, emanation, construction and artistic expression, stewardship and the goodness of creation, and the challenges to a good Creator.
What you need to know
Answer each one before you reveal it.
Why does Buber's account make theology about God awkward?
Explain what is meant by divine omnipotence and where it creates difficulty.
Questions from this subtopic
Each one with the model answer underneath.
- 1
What do Christians mean when they call God personal?
Model answer
That God is not an impersonal force or principle but a being who knows, wills, loves and can be addressed. Christians hold that God enters into relationship with individuals, hears prayer, and reveals himself by name rather than merely being inferred. Personal language does not mean God is a human being writ large; most theologians treat it as analogy, since God has no body and is not one item among the world's objects.
- 2
How does M Buber's distinction between two kinds of relation help explain a personal God?
Model answer
Buber, a Jewish philosopher whose work Christian theologians took up widely, contrasted I-Thou with I-It. In I-It we treat something as an object to be analysed, used or classified. In I-Thou we meet another whole being in mutual presence, without reducing them to a function. Buber argued that God is the Eternal Thou who can never be turned into an It, and that every genuine I-Thou meeting is a glimpse of that ultimate relation.
- 3
Why does Buber's account make theology about God awkward?
Model answer
Because the moment God becomes a topic to be described, measured or proved, God has been shifted into the It column. Buber's point is that God is known in encounter, in address and response, not by assembling propositions. Christians who use him tend to say doctrine is a servant of relationship, mapping the encounter afterwards rather than replacing it. Critics reply that without some cognitive content there is no way to tell a genuine encounter from a mood.
- 4
Contrast what Buber and Augustine each contribute to belief in God.
Model answer
Buber works from the side of encounter: God is the Eternal Thou, known in address and relation, and reduced to an idol the moment he is treated as an object of analysis. Augustine works from the side of God's nature and God's act: God is the unchanging source who creates freely out of nothing, whose creation is good, and in whom evil has no positive existence. One secures that God can be met, the other that God is worth meeting; Christians who use both argue that relationship without doctrine drifts and doctrine without relationship dies.
- 5
Explain what is meant by divine omnipotence and where it creates difficulty.
Model answer
Omnipotence is the claim that God's power is unlimited. Most Christian thinkers qualify it: God cannot do the logically incoherent, and cannot act against his own nature by lying or willing evil. Difficulties follow. If God can do anything, why is there so much suffering? And if human beings are genuinely free, has God limited his own power? Some theologians answer that God freely restrains his power out of love, which keeps the relationship real.
- 6
What is immutability, and why do some Christians find it hard to reconcile with a personal God?
Model answer
Immutability is the doctrine that God does not change in nature, character, will or purpose. Classical theists such as Augustine held that change means either improvement or decline, and a perfect being can do neither. The tension is obvious: a God who responds to prayer, is moved by suffering, or becomes incarnate looks like a God who changes. Defenders answer that God's constancy is exactly what makes his responses trustworthy; the change is in the creature's situation, not in God's steady love.
Other ways to work this
The same content, four other ways.
What is inside Levo
Six ways to work the same material.
Every question in Christianity, on a schedule.
Attempt a question from memory, write the correct version, then attempt it again. Levo records the jump between your first attempt and your last, and brings each question back on the day you are due to forget it.
Or £46 a year, about £3.83 a month. Cancel anytime.