Islam, Secularisation and the Modern World

Overview

Recall questions on secularisation, Shari'ah under secular law and religious councils, literalist, traditionalist and modernist readings, the liberationist strand, migration, modesty and entertainment, and Nasr and Mona Siddiqui on the modern world.

What you need to know

Answer each one before you reveal it.

Questions from this subtopic

Each one with the model answer underneath.

1. 1

   What does secularisation actually name, and why does it complicate matters for Muslims?

   Model answer

   It covers several different things at once: the separation of religion from state power, the decline of religious belief and practice, and the confining of religion to private life. Muslims who accept the first often reject the third, because a tradition with a comprehensive law does not divide neatly into public and private. That is why Muslim responses cannot be sorted simply into for and against.

2. 2

   How is Shari'ah applied where Muslims live under secular law?

   Model answer

   Mostly in personal and voluntary form: worship, diet, dress, finance and family arrangements. In Britain religious councils issue rulings and, in particular, religious divorces that only such a body can grant, and some disputes are handled through arbitration. Islamic banking and halal certification are the commercial expression. State law remains supreme throughout, and the argument is about how much accommodation is appropriate rather than about which law governs.

3. 3

   What is the criticism of religious councils in Western countries?

   Model answer

   That women can be pressed into using them and can be disadvantaged in the outcomes, particularly over divorce and custody, and that a parallel system risks leaving people outside the protection of ordinary law. Defenders reply that many women approach them precisely to obtain a religious divorce unobtainable elsewhere, and that closing them would leave those women trapped in marriages they cannot exit. Mona Siddiqui is among the Muslim scholars who have pressed the criticism from within.

4. 4

   What interpretive positions do Muslims take on the authority of the law today?

   Model answer

   Literalist and Salafi-influenced positions hold that the texts yield clear rulings and that later accretions should be stripped away. Traditionalists work within the classical schools and their accumulated method. Modernist reformers separate the divine law from human jurisprudence and argue that the law's purposes should govern its application. Some argue that a secular state is the best guarantor of the freedom in which faith can be genuine at all. Each of them claims fidelity to revelation.

5. 5

   How is the validity of literalist, traditionalist and modernist readings of Islamic law argued, and what follows in practice?

   Model answer

   By appeal to method: whether the interpreter is qualified, whether a ruling has a real basis in the sources, whether analogy and the public good have been applied properly, and whether the reading serves the recognised aims of protecting religion, life, reason, family and property. The dispute over who may interpret is as sharp as any dispute over content. What follows is concrete: whether an interest-bearing mortgage may be taken, whether insurance is permitted, what dress is required, how far men and women may mix, and how much of the surrounding society may be joined.

6. 6

   What is the liberationist strand in modern Islam?

   Model answer

   A reading that takes the Qur'an's insistence on justice for the poor and the oppressed as its interpretive key. Farid Esack developed it during the struggle against apartheid, arguing that the text is read rightly only from the side of the oppressed and that this grounds solidarity across religious lines. Ali Shariati had earlier fused Shi'a symbolism with anti-imperial politics in Iran, casting Karbala as a permanent summons against tyranny. Critics say the approach imports a political programme; its advocates answer that it restores the Qur'an's own priorities.

Other ways to work this

The same content, four other ways.

What is inside Levo

Six ways to work the same material.