WJEC A-Level Government and Politics 603-1979-3
The British Constitution
The Judiciary and the Supreme Court
The UK Executive
Parliament and the Accountability of Government
Government and the Senedd in Wales
Devolution and the United Kingdom
Citizenship and Rights
The Protection of Human Rights
Democracy and Participation
Electoral Systems in the UK
Voting Behaviour in the UK
Political Parties in Wales and the UK
Pressure Groups and Social Movements
Liberalism
Conservatism
Socialism and Communism
Nationalism
The US Constitution and Federalism
Rights and Liberties in the USA
The US Congress
The US Presidency
The US Supreme Court
US Elections and Voting Behaviour
Political Parties in the USA
Devolution and the United Kingdom
Asymmetry in the devolution settlement
- 3 things to know
- AS Unit 1
Overview
Recall questions on how the three settlements differ in powers, structure and electoral system, why Wales changed most often, England's position, and the case for symmetry.
What you need to know
Answer each one before you reveal it.
Define asymmetry in the context of UK devolution.
Give one way the powers of the Scottish Parliament differ from those of the Senedd.
Questions from this subtopic
Each one with the model answer underneath.
- 1
Define asymmetry in the context of UK devolution.
Model answer
Asymmetry means each nation has a different set of powers, institutions and electoral arrangements, so no single model applies across the UK.
- 2
Give one way the powers of the Scottish Parliament differ from those of the Senedd.
Model answer
Scotland has control of policing, prisons, prosecution and its own courts, while justice in Wales remains reserved.
- 3
Give one way the Northern Ireland institutions differ structurally from those in Scotland and Wales.
Model answer
Northern Ireland has mandatory power-sharing with ministerial posts allocated by party strength, rather than a government formed by whichever side can command a majority.
- 4
Compare the electoral systems used for the three devolved legislatures.
Model answer
Scotland has used the Additional Member System, Northern Ireland uses the single transferable vote, and Wales used the Additional Member System before moving to closed lists.
- 5
Explain why the Welsh settlement changed more often than the Scottish one.
Model answer
Wales began with only secondary law-making under a conferred powers model, so each extension of power needed a new statute, while Scotland started with primary powers under a reserved model.
- 6
Give two causes of asymmetry in the UK settlement.
Model answer
Devolution was granted separately to each nation in response to different levels of demand, and Northern Ireland's arrangements were shaped by the need to end a conflict.
Other ways to work this
The same content, four other ways.
What is inside Levo
Six ways to work the same material.
Every question in Devolution and the United Kingdom, on a schedule.
Attempt a question from memory, write the correct version, then attempt it again. Levo records the jump between your first attempt and your last, and brings each question back on the day you are due to forget it.
Or £46 a year, about £3.83 a month. Cancel anytime.