Evaluation
CCEA A-Level Government and Politics 4830
The Northern Ireland Assembly
Topic overviewThe Good Friday Agreement: origins and principlesThe three strands of the AgreementRights, equality, policing and prisoners under the AgreementImplementing the Agreement: referendums, devolution and suspensionSubsequent agreements from St Andrews to New Decade, New ApproachComposition, elections and designationCross-community voting and the petition of concernThe Assembly's representative functionThe Assembly's legislative functionThe Assembly's scrutiny functionThe Assembly's independence of the Executive
The Northern Ireland Executive Committee
Topic overviewThe composition of the Executive CommitteeAppointing the Executive and the d'Hondt formulaThe First Minister and deputy First MinisterThe Office of the First Minister and deputy First MinisterThe Pledge of Office and the Ministerial CodeHow the Executive determines legislationThe Programme for Government and the budgetDivisions within the ExecutiveEvaluating the Executive's policy makingThe Executive as a power-sharing governmentCollapse, restoration and reform of the Executive
The Northern Ireland Political Parties
Topic overviewThe role and functions of political partiesThe Northern Ireland party systemThe Democratic Unionist PartySinn FéinThe Ulster Unionist PartyThe Social Democratic and Labour PartyThe Alliance PartySmaller parties and independentsChanging party strategies since 1998Changing electoral support since 1998Explaining electoral change
The UK Parliament
Topic overviewRepresentation in the House of CommonsLegislation and the passage of a bill through the CommonsScrutiny of government on the floor of the CommonsSelect committees and the scrutiny of governmentThe effectiveness of the House of CommonsComposition and representation in the House of LordsThe House of Lords and the legislative processScrutiny and committee work in the House of LordsThe effectiveness of the House of LordsThe fusion of powers and executive control of ParliamentParty discipline, backbench independence and parliamentary privilege
The UK Executive
Topic overviewThe role of the Prime MinisterThe powers of the Prime MinisterThe Cabinet and its roleCabinet committees, the Cabinet Office and the core executiveMinisterial responsibilityLimitations on the powers of the Prime MinisterThe Executive and its control of the legislaturePrime ministerial government or cabinet governmentThe civil service, special advisers and the centre of government
Option: The British JudiciaryJudiciary
Topic overviewThe judiciary, the rule of law and the separation of powersThe courts and the United Kingdom Supreme CourtJudicial review and its groundsJudicial review and the Human Rights ActLandmark rulings against the ExecutiveJudicial inquiriesWhat secures judicial independenceTensions between the judiciary and the ExecutiveThe effectiveness of the judiciary in holding the Executive to account
Option: Pressure Groups in the UKPressure groups
Topic overviewThe concept of a pressure groupCause and sectional pressure groupsInsider and outsider pressure groupsSocial movementsPressure groups and the policy-making processInsider tactics: lobbying, consultation and the courtsOutsider tactics: protest, direct action and the mediaWhat makes a pressure group successfulPluralist, elitist and New Right interpretations of impactRegulating lobbying and the debate about influence
USA Option: The Legislative BranchUSA
Topic overviewThe constitutional basis of CongressMembership, elections and termsThe representative role of CongressThe legislative processThe committee systemScrutiny, oversight and impeachmentThe exclusive powers of the SenateParties, leadership and polarisationAssessing the effectiveness of CongressPressure and lobby groups and CongressCongress and the President
USA Option: The Executive BranchUSA
Topic overviewThe constitutional role of the PresidentThe roles the President performsThe formal and informal powers of the executiveThe Cabinet and the executive departmentsThe Executive Office of the PresidentExecutive orders, agreements and unilateral actionConstraints on the exercise of executive powerHow amendments and the courts have shaped the presidencyLobby groups and the executive branchThe executive and CongressPower, responsibility and accountability in the American executive
USA Option: Comparative Government and PoliticsUSA
Topic overviewSeparation of powers and fusion of powersStructures of the two legislatures comparedPowers of the two legislatures comparedParty discipline and the operation of the two legislaturesRepresentation compared across the four chambersLegislation compared across the four chambersScrutiny compared across the four chambersEvaluating the effectiveness of the four chambersAppointment and removal of the two executives comparedThe powers of the two executives comparedConstraints, accountability and the effectiveness of the two executives
Ireland Option: The Legislative BranchIreland
Topic overviewBunreacht na hÉireann and the role of the OireachtasDáil Éireann: composition, election and termSingle transferable vote in multi-seat constituenciesSeanad Éireann: composition and selectionHow a bill becomes law in the OireachtasThe Oireachtas and representationScrutiny, questions and the committee systemThe effectiveness of Dáil Éireann and Dáil reformThe effectiveness of Seanad Éireann and the reform debateThe judiciary, the courts and the legislative branchThe Oireachtas and the executive
Ireland Option: The Executive BranchIreland
Topic overviewBunreacht na hÉireann and the executive powerThe Taoiseach: appointment, powers and constraintsThe Tánaiste, ministers and the shape of the GovernmentCabinet government and the executive processThe President and the executive branchCoalition government and how it shapes the executiveMinisterial responsibility and accountabilityThe executive and the OireachtasThe judiciary and the executive branchFormal constitutional amendment and the executiveInformal constitutional change and the executive
Ireland Option: Comparative Government and PoliticsIreland
Topic overviewCodified and uncodified constitutions comparedThe structures of the Oireachtas and Parliament comparedElecting the Dáil and the Commons: PR-STV and first past the postSeanad Éireann and the House of Lords comparedRepresentation comparedMaking law: the legislative process comparedScrutiny and accountability comparedAppointing the two executivesThe powers of the two executives comparedConstraints on the two executives comparedEvaluating the power, accountability and effectiveness of the two executives
Political Power: The Exercise of Political PowerPolitical Power
Topic overviewPower, authority and influenceLegitimacy and the grounds of obedienceSocial, economic, religious and international factors in legitimacyCreating and maintaining legitimacy across political systemsCoercion and its effectivenessDictatorship, authoritarianism and oligarchyThe nature and effectiveness of authoritarian ruleDemocracy and democratic legitimacyHuman and civil rightsState survival and state collapse
Political Power: Theories of Political PowerPolitical Power
Topic overviewStudying the origin, nature and distribution of powerPluralism and the diffusion of powerCriticisms of pluralism and elite pluralismMarxism, the ruling class and the capitalist stateNeo-Marxism, hegemony and the relative autonomy of the stateClassical elite theoryModern elite theory and elite ruleFeminism, patriarchy and political powerThe theories applied to different political systemsEvaluating the four theories of power
Political Ideas: Mill, on LibertyPolitical Ideas
Topic overviewMill, On Liberty and the one very simple principleThe harm principleSelf-regarding and other-regarding conductThreats to individual libertyThe tyranny of the majorityLiberty of thought and discussionIndividuality and experiments of livingHuman rationality, progress and Mill's exceptionsThe role of the state in On LibertyCriticisms of On Liberty
Political Ideas: Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in FrancePolitical Ideas
Topic overviewBurke, the Reflections and the occasion of the bookBurke's view of human natureReason, prejudice and prescriptionCustom, tradition and the partnership between generationsThe attack on abstract rightsGradual change and the case for reformSocial inequality, property and natural aristocracyPolitical authority, religion and the role of the stateBurke's critique of the revolutionaries' methodCriticisms of the Reflections
Political Ideas: Marx and Engels, the Communist ManifestoPolitical Ideas
Topic overviewThe Manifesto, its authors and its occasionClass struggle and the materialist view of historyThe bourgeoisie as a revolutionary classThe nature of capitalism and its crisesThe exploitation of the working classSocial divisions, the other classes and class consciousnessThe demise of capitalism and the proletarian revolutionPrivate property and the ten measuresThe nature of socialism and the role of the stateCriticisms of The Communist Manifesto
Political Ideas: LiberalismPolitical Ideas
Topic overviewThe core ideas of liberalismThe liberal view of human nature and human reasonNegative and positive freedomThreats to individual libertyLiberal equalityThe liberal stateClassical liberalismModern liberalismLiberalism and democracyEvidence for and criticisms of liberal principlesLiberalism compared with conservatism and socialism
Political Ideas: ConservatismPolitical Ideas
Topic overviewThe core ideas of conservatismThe conservative view of human natureCustom, tradition and prescriptionThe need for gradual changeThe organic societyAuthority, hierarchy and social inequalityOne-nation conservatismLibertarian conservatism and the New RightEvidence for and criticisms of conservative principlesConservatism compared with liberalism and socialism
Political Ideas: SocialismPolitical Ideas
Topic overviewThe core ideas of socialismThe socialist view of human natureThe socialist critique of capitalismSocialist equalityIndividual liberty in socialist thoughtFraternity, community and co-operationThe role of the state in socialist thoughtRevolutionary socialismReformist socialism and social democracyEvidence for and criticisms of socialist principlesSocialism compared with liberalism and conservatism
Political Ideas: Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France
Criticisms of the Reflections
- 3 things to know
- A2 Unit 2
Overview
James Mackintosh's criticism of Burke, factual criticism of Burke's account of events in France and charge of inconsistency levelled against Burke.
What you need to know
Answer each one before you reveal it.
Your recallNot started
Evaluation
What is the criticism that prescription can justify injustice?
Evaluation
What is the liberal criticism of Burke's rejection of abstract rights?
Questions from this subtopic
Each one with the model answer underneath.
- 1
Who wrote the first published reply to Burke, and what was the argument?
Model answer
Mary Wollstonecraft replied within weeks in A Vindication of the Rights of Men. Wollstonecraft argued that Burke's reverence for property, rank and antiquity had displaced any concern for justice, and that his sympathy went to a queen rather than to the poor.
- 2
Summarise Thomas Paine's answer to Burke.
Model answer
Paine argued in Rights of Man that rights belong to people by nature and that each generation must be free to govern itself. Paine accused Burke of pitying the plumage and forgetting the dying bird, meaning that Burke mourned the fallen court while ignoring the suffering of the French people.
- 3
How did Paine attack the partnership between the generations?
Model answer
Paine argued that the dead have no authority over the living and that no assembly can bind posterity for ever. Paine called the presumption of governing beyond the grave the most ridiculous and insolent of all tyrannies.
- 4
State James Mackintosh's criticism of Burke.
Model answer
Mackintosh argued in Vindiciae Gallicae that the French institutions Burke wished to preserve were corrupt and incapable of reform, so demolition was the only realistic course. Mackintosh later moved closer to Burke's position as the Revolution turned violent.
- 5
What is the factual criticism of Burke's account of events in France?
Model answer
Critics point out that Burke never visited revolutionary France, relied on partial correspondence, and gave a theatrical account of the October Days. His picture of the abuses of the old regime is also widely regarded as far too gentle.
- 6
What is the charge of inconsistency levelled against Burke?
Model answer
Critics ask how the defender of the American colonists and of Irish Catholics could condemn the French so completely. Burke's answer is that the Americans defended established rights while the French invented abstract ones, but critics regard the distinction as convenient.
Other ways to work this
The same content, four other ways.
What is inside Levo
Six ways to work the same material.
Every question in Political Ideas: Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France, on a schedule.
Attempt a question from memory, write the correct version, then attempt it again. Levo records the jump between your first attempt and your last, and brings each question back on the day you are due to forget it.
Or £46 a year, about £3.83 a month. Cancel anytime.