Eduqas A-Level Law A150QS
Parliamentary and European Law Making
Delegated Legislation
Statutory Interpretation
Judicial Precedent
The Civil Courts and Civil Process
The Criminal Process
Legal Personnel
Access to Justice and Funding
Contract: Rules and Theory of Contract LawContract
Contract: Essential Requirements and FormationContract
Contract: Express and Implied TermsContract
Contract: Misrepresentation and Economic DuressContract
Contract: Discharge of ContractContract
Contract: RemediesContract
Tort: Rules and Theory of Tort LawTort
Tort: NegligenceTort
Tort: Occupiers' LiabilityTort
Tort: Torts Connected to LandTort
Tort: Vicarious LiabilityTort
Tort: Defences and RemediesTort
Criminal Law: Rules and TheoryCriminal
Criminal Law: General Elements of LiabilityCriminal
Criminal Law: Offences Against the PersonCriminal
Criminal Law: Property OffencesCriminal
Criminal Law: Capacity DefencesCriminal
Criminal Law: Necessity Defences and Preliminary OffencesCriminal
Human Rights: Rules and TheoryHuman rights
Human Rights: Protection of Rights and Freedoms in the UKHuman rights
Human Rights: Convention ProvisionsHuman rights
Human Rights: Restrictions on Convention RightsHuman rights
Human Rights: EnforcementHuman rights
Human Rights: ReformHuman rights
Human Rights: Protection of Rights and Freedoms in the UK
Criticisms of human rights and a UK Bill of Rights
- 3 things to know
- Components 2 and 3
Overview
Democratic legitimacy criticism of judicially enforced rights, criticism of mission creep at Strasbourg and UK Bill of Rights.
What you need to know
Answer each one before you reveal it.
Which Strasbourg ruling on prisoner voting provoked strong criticism in the United Kingdom?
Which deportation case is often cited by critics of Convention rights?
Questions from this subtopic
Each one with the model answer underneath.
- 1
What is the criminals' charter criticism of the Human Rights Act 1998?
Model answer
Critics argue that the Act is used mainly by prisoners, suspects and offenders resisting deportation. Supporters reply that a guarantee protecting only popular claimants would not be a right at all.
- 2
Which Strasbourg ruling on prisoner voting provoked strong criticism in the United Kingdom?
Model answer
Hirst v United Kingdom (No 2) (2005) held that a blanket ban on prisoner voting breached the right to free elections. The United Kingdom kept the general ban and answered in 2017 with a narrow administrative change.
- 3
Which deportation case is often cited by critics of Convention rights?
Model answer
Othman v United Kingdom (2012) blocked the deportation of Abu Qatada to Jordan because of the risk of evidence obtained by torture. Deportation followed in 2013 after Jordan gave treaty assurances about the retrial.
- 4
State the democratic legitimacy criticism of judicially enforced rights.
Model answer
Critics argue that unelected judges should not settle contested moral and political questions. Defenders answer that judges decide only whether a limit on a right can be justified in law.
- 5
What is meant by the criticism of mission creep at Strasbourg?
Model answer
Critics say the Court has extended the Convention into areas the drafters never contemplated, such as prisoner voting. Supporters answer that the living instrument approach is what has kept the Convention relevant.
- 6
How do defenders of the Human Rights Act 1998 answer its critics?
Model answer
Defenders point to cases won by bereaved families, patients, soldiers and victims of crime. The duty of effective investigation into deaths involving the state is given as a leading example.
Other ways to work this
The same content, four other ways.
What is inside Levo
Six ways to work the same material.
Every question in Human Rights: Protection of Rights and Freedoms in the UK, on a schedule.
Attempt a question from memory, write the correct version, then attempt it again. Levo records the jump between your first attempt and your last, and brings each question back on the day you are due to forget it.
Or £46 a year, about £3.83 a month. Cancel anytime.